- Статьи
- Society
- Capital of the 2nd rank: how a Navy officer made a fortune trading in medals and fakes
Capital of the 2nd rank: how a Navy officer made a fortune trading in medals and fakes
Maxim Koshkarev, an officer of the Northern Fleet accused of manufacturing and selling fake works by Ernst Neizvestny, may be a well-known player in the semi-underground antique market, Izvestia has established. Since the mid-2000s, he has been selling state awards, which is prohibited by law, precious metals, diamond jewelry, and may be involved in the smuggling of cultural property. There is a possibility that he planned to sell fakes of Renoir, Picasso, Dali and other famous artists, claiming that he inherited the paintings. The turnover of his business could be measured in tens of millions of rubles, and the officer converted the profits into expensive cars and real estate, sources told Izvestia. The details of the second life of a ship supplier of the Russian Navy are in our investigation.
A naval supply officer with a love of faleristics
Maxim Koshkarev graduated from the Volsky branch of the Military Academy of Logistics and Transport in 2002. He was assigned to the Northern Fleet, to the position of assistant commander of the Peter the Great cruiser for supply. The last position of captain of the 2nd rank is Deputy Chief of Staff of the 43rd Division of missile ships.
Koshkarev combined his service with scientific activity. For example, he is listed as a co-author of the article "The Northern Sea Route as a space for coordinating interests for sustainable socio-economic development of the Arctic" in the scientific journal "Arctic: Ecology and Economics". In it, Koshkarev is represented by an assistant at the Department of Public and Municipal Management at the Institute of Business Career. The author's email address is also listed there: karakas@inbox.ru . This is an important fact, as it allows you to link two areas of an officer's activity: service in the navy and the antiques trade.
Koshkarev began leaving his first digital footprints on the antiques market back in the late 2000s. The alias of karakas7 in connection with the postal address karakas@inbox.ru Based on open data, he used at least four Russian and foreign specialized sites.
Among them is the faleristics forum.info, one of the largest platforms for the illegal trade in state awards, whose activities were previously reported by Izvestia.
The main trading platform for Koshkarev was the Ukrainian portal "Forums-SU", known among collectors as "Drying" — they sell orders, coins, knives and other antiques. An Alex95 user with an email address is registered on this site karakas@inbox.ru — the same as Maxim Koshkarev's.

In total, since registering in February 2009, this user has written 5848 messages, which may indicate thousands of items sold.
Alex95's main interest was in the legally prohibited purchase and resale of Soviet and Russian state awards, Izvestia determined after examining the subject matter of most of this user's messages. Moreover, he specialized only in expensive items. So, in 2013, he proudly wrote in one of his posts that he had already sold more than 40 "foreheads" (Orders of Lenin). The most expensive of them was the order, which was awarded to the former People's Commissar of Armaments, USSR Defense Minister Dmitry Ustinov — the item went under the hammer for $ 6.5 thousand, while the price of ordinary "Lenin" fluctuates around $ 3-4 thousand. Only these sales could bring Koshkarev, if he was hiding under the nickname Alex95, more than 10 million rubles.

Some of Koshkarev's messages may indicate that he allegedly received part of the profits from organizing the smuggling of cultural property. "I know languages, the Internet and forums well, where you are lazy to search or are afraid of problems with customs and the law. I solve these problems and get my margin," Alex95 wrote on the Forums-SU portal in 2009.
In the same message, he apologized for the long absence due to the fact that "the cruiser was docked." According to media reports, around this time, the Peter the Great cruiser, on which Koshkarev served, returned to Severomorsk from a six-month trip to the Indian Ocean. After such long voyages, ships usually undergo docking, technical inspection and maintenance.

Koshkarev organized one of the possible smuggling channels in Ukraine. According to him, "relatives in Lugansk" helped him to transport valuables to and from Russia in the noughties. In addition to the orders, he was noted for buying and selling coins, precious metals bars, diamonds and jewelry.
How could a Naval officer get into the antique business
According to Koshkarev himself, Yuri Kuznetsov, an officer of the auxiliary fleet, brought him into the business of trading antiques, including state awards.
"Yesterday, my colleague Yura Kuznetsov died suddenly in St. Petersburg. Aneurysm of the brain. Yura brought me to the forum 14 years ago. Without exaggeration, he became a mentor. He was a professional and just a wonderful man, a knight of the Order of the Red Star, served in the Navy on ships of the Russian Navy," Koshkarev wrote in June 2020.
According to other reports, Kuznetsov was Koshkarev's main representative in St. Petersburg.
"In the mid-1990s, a fairly large community of antiquity lovers formed in the Northern Fleet, the backbone of which was made up of phalerists, mock—ups and reenactors," an antique dealer from Severomorsk told Izvestia on condition of anonymity. — Most of them were active officers and midshipmen, who eventually established close business ties with antique dealers in Moscow and St. Petersburg.
On the Forums-SU portal, Koshkarev was regularly accused of trying to sell fake orders and other insignia and even offered to assign him the status of a problem seller. He managed to gain an ambiguous reputation in the legal faleristics market.
— We know this man firsthand and also had some problems with him, — Ilya Goryanov, president of the auction house "Sign", told Izvestia. — He tried to buy awards from the tsarist period, made a purchase, but did not pay the bills. I know that other major auction houses in Moscow had exactly the same problems with him. The man was known for his inadequacy and dishonesty, but at the same time he presented himself as a major collector from Murmansk and demanded to be treated, I quote, "with great respect."
According to Ilya Goryanov, unscrupulous resellers use the scheme when a buyer makes a purchase but does not pay bills. After making a purchase at an auction, the reseller begins to offer the item on other sites and, if he finds a buyer who has offered a higher price, pays for the lot and promptly resells it at a profit. If there are no profitable offers, then the lot remains unpaid. In this case, the auction is forced to put it up for sale again and explain to the owners of the item.
Love of painting and creativity of the Unknown
In 2011, there was an episode that could indicate Koshkarev's intention to expand his activities through works of art. A message from the user karakas7 appeared on the large forum of collectors, antiques and art dealers UUU, who made inquiries about how and to whom paintings by Dali, Monet, Renoir, Toulouse-Lautrec, Picasso, Degas and Chagall could be sold. The user explained that he allegedly inherited a large collection of paintings.

The user indicated Vladimir as his city, but the forum participants probably recognized Koshkarev by his nickname and ironically commented on the message: "Dali, Monet and Picasso are better to sell at their place of residence — in Murmansk, only there, unlike abroad or the capital, they will be able to offer you a real price."
As a result, Monet, Chagall and Picasso did not appear on sale. But in 2014, the same user registered on the site. artinvestment.ru , which is related to UUU. Among the paintings he sold in the next 10 years were mostly inexpensive works by Murmansk authors. But in 2023, Koshkarev put up for auction two works, claiming that they were created by Ernst Neizvestny — the illustration "The Screaming Prophet" for 300 thousand rubles and the canvas "Birth in Pain" for $ 8 thousand. It was the interest in the work of an Unknown Man, but already in 2026, that led to the criminal case and the arrest of Koshkarev.


Love of cars and real estate
The naval officer converted his off-duty income into expensive cars and luxury real estate, sources told Izvestia. This is confirmed by open information. So, according to reports on Russia's largest BMW Club forum, user karakas7 from the Murmansk region has changed at least three expensive cars in 10 years — BMW 3, BMW X6, BMW X5. Interestingly, on the same forum, karakas7 was interested in the possibility of deleting from the Rosreestr database the record of the share in the parent's apartment in order to get housing through the service line. Other users responded by saying that what he was asking for was a criminal offense.

Koshkarev, apparently, actively invested in the capital's real estate. At the BMW Club forum mentioned above, he put up for sale at least two Moscow apartments: in 2013, an apartment on Ryazansky Prospekt for 4.8 million rubles, and two years later, a one—bedroom apartment with an area of 48 square meters. m in the village of Kommunarka. Also, according to Izvestia's sources, Koshkarev could purchase for personal use a two-bedroom apartment in the capital's business class residential complex "Level Prichalny" (prices for the most modest three-bedroom apartment start from 35 million rubles) and an apartment in Sochi.

According to the Investigative Committee, as part of the case of trafficking in fake works by Ernst Neizvestny, the court seized Koshkarev's property for a total amount of 128 million rubles.
Part of a large counterfeit market
The case of Maxim Koshkarev is just one of the numerous episodes of the large—scale trade in fake art objects. According to experts of the antique market, the situation with fakes is taking on an alarming scale.
"Fakes have flooded the market, and in our practice there was a case when 55 out of 56 paintings in one of the avant—garde collections turned out to be fake," Matvey Levant, president of the Levant and Partners law firm, told Izvestia. — Fakes are put up for auction, sometimes they end up in museums, and their turnover does not stop. One of the main reasons is that there is no regulation of art purchase and sale transactions in Russia. It is necessary to stop this mess, in particular, non-documentary transactions should be banned and publicized as much as possible.
According to the source, the institute for the examination of works of art for their authenticity in Russia also needs to be reformed. It is not uncommon for the same collectible to have two contradictory examinations, and there are also known cases when museums refuse to accept works for exhibitions whose authenticity was previously confirmed by their own staff.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»