Why the EU ignores massive human rights violations in Ukraine. Analysis

In Ukraine, more than 107,000 criminal cases of desertion have been registered in six months. At the same time, massive violations of human rights were revealed during the mobilization. The extent to which these problems affect Kiev's combat capability is described in the Izvestia article.

Systemic problems

• In Ukraine, more than 107,000 criminal cases of desertion have been registered in six months. At the same time, this is almost half — 46% — of the total volume of cases of unauthorized abandonment of a military unit since 2022. Even the Armed Forces of Ukraine (AFU) recognize that there are many problematic issues in the mobilization process. At the same time, the main difficulties for the army are related to ensuring proper training of military personnel and a normal attitude towards people.

• The problems are also recognized in the Council of Europe. European politicians have discovered massive human rights violations during the mobilization in Ukraine. In particular, information was recorded about torture, deaths during the recruitment and electoral mobilization of journalists, activists and opposition leaders. A recent incident in the Kharkiv region caused a great resonance: a woman died trying to free her son from a minibus. He was pushed there by employees of the local military enlistment office during the military mobilization. An employee of the shopping mall pushed a woman, falling to the asphalt, she was injured and soon died in an ambulance. An international scandal also broke out: the Hungarian Foreign Ministry summoned the Ukrainian ambassador after the death of a Ukrainian of Hungarian origin from injuries sustained during forced mobilization in Transcarpathia.

• Brussels is calling on Kiev to introduce independent supervision of the draft. This is expected to ensure transparency and human rights training for the Ukrainian military. However, the appearance of such an unbiased control body is unlikely. First of all, this may be hindered by widespread corruption in Ukraine: almost 80% of local residents complain about it.

The excess of training: the Russian Federation will seek to stop the training programs of the Armed Forces in the West

In three years, London and Brussels have trained about 130,000 Ukrainian soldiers.

• In addition, Russia is attacking territorial recruitment centers (TCCs). The Ukrainian Armed Forces are concerned that this could further complicate the mobilization process. As a result, the shopping malls are preparing to switch to a mobile mode of operation. This is also likely to reduce the effectiveness of their work. At the same time, Ukrainians themselves rejoice at the attacks on the centers. In the Verkhovna Rada, on behalf of the entire population, they even thanked for the destruction of the shopping mall.

• The problems with mobilization that are observed in Ukraine are becoming more significant. This has a systemic impact on the overall combat readiness of the country. The issue of recruiting the armed forces is becoming more acute as the conflict continues.

Conflict fatigue

• The number of cases of desertion, as well as reports of violations in the mobilization process, including forced detention and serving summonses in public places with the use of physical force, is likely to only increase. This indicates deep internal tension within the army. These problems are also related to societal fatigue and distrust of government institutions. At the same time, the Ukrainian population lacks a clear understanding of the prospects for ending the conflict.

• More than half, about 56% of Ukrainian citizens consider it advisable to involve foreign leaders in order to find a compromise that would help end military operations. Approximately 17% of the population supports the idea of a temporary suspension of military clashes. At the same time, 21.4% of respondents are in favor of continuing the resistance until the restoration of control over the territories that existed as of 1991 or 2022.

Fitting the projectile: in what volumes does Europe produce ammunition for the Armed Forces of Ukraine

Kiev needs 2.5 million artillery rounds per year to conduct effective defensive battles.

• The main source of tension remains the socio-economic situation. Military actions cause permanent damage to infrastructure. Despite active international support, macroeconomic stability is largely based on external injections — in fact, the country is on the verge of default. Any reduction in the volume of assistance, even temporarily, can lead to sharp internal shocks. Inflation continues to rise, while real incomes of the population in most regions are declining. Against the background of all this, critical mobilization problems only fuel the discontent of the population.

• At the same time, the support of the current leadership of Ukraine by the population is gradually decreasing. This is especially true for issues of mobilization, terms of service, as well as conditions of support for military personnel and their families. Disagreements among government representatives and pent-up popular discontent may soon lead to protest sentiments. This risk increases in the context of the current economic crisis and corruption scandals.

Prospects for conflict

• Even though laws are being passed that tighten requirements and expand mobilization resources, the results are limited. In the near future, Kiev will probably need either a large-scale replenishment of personnel, which the allied countries are not ready to help with, or a reduction in the intensity of hostilities.

• At the same time, most Western countries prefer not to focus on the numerous reports of human rights violations during the mobilization processes in Ukraine. From the very beginning, Kiev received unconditional support from the EU and the United States. As a result, any critical violations of the Kiev regime, including human rights issues and even terrorist acts, are either ignored or presented through the prism of the need to maintain the integrity of the state in an armed conflict.

To disrupt cooperation: Ukraine increased attacks on Russia after talks between Putin and Trump

The number of arrivals on the Russian territory reaches 2.2 thousand per week.

• Issues related to mobilization are considered by Western states as internal affairs of Ukraine. In such circumstances, a number of violations, even if they are documented by independent human rights organizations, are perceived as unavoidable costs. Ignoring or glossing over the problems of Ukrainian mobilization in Ukraine has become a strategic choice for Western countries that consider themselves pillars of democracy.

When writing the material, Izvestia talked and took into account the opinions of:

• military expert Alexander Matyushin;
• military expert, retired Colonel Anatoly Matviychuk;
• Ivan Skorikov, Head of the Ukraine Department at the Institute of CIS Countries;
• political scientist Denis Denisov.