Expense account: parents are asked to keep their early retirement benefits
The government has proposed to establish a mandatory two-month parental leave: if a person starts working earlier, he will lose the right to benefits, which are paid until the children reach the age of one and a half years. Now you can make a payment and immediately return to work, including full-time. The Association of the Self-employed of Russia has asked the State Duma to reconsider the initiative, fearing that the new requirements will affect parents who need additional funds. Experts and MPs also point to the risk of infringement of the rights of families who find themselves in a difficult financial situation. Why the authorities propose to review the current procedure and what the new restriction may lead to is in the Izvestia article.
Who can be deprived of benefits
In Russia, they ask not to set a minimum period of parental leave — two months — in order to maintain support measures. Such a letter was sent to the State Duma by the Association of the Self-Employed of Russia (OSR), Izvestia got acquainted with it.
At the end of October, the Russian government introduced two bills proposing such changes. That is, if a parent goes to work earlier, he will lose the right to benefits until the child reaches the age of one and a half years. The new rule is proposed to be introduced from January 1, 2027.
Today, a monthly child care payment for up to one and a half years is assigned to someone who has taken maternity leave — to a mother, father or other relative, said Alyona Lovochkina, chief of staff of the independent trade union Novy Trud. To do this, it is enough to submit an application to the employer, and the Social Fund transfers the benefit. Its size is 40% of the average earnings for the previous two years.
"Starting in 2024, parents have the right to receive payments and work at the same time," she said. — It was the right decision. It reinforced a simple idea: modern families live in different ways, and the state should not force them to choose between a child and financial stability.
According to Marina Koyushkova, director of the OCR, the new rule will primarily affect parents who form a budget through basic work under an employment contract, self-employment as a part-time job and a monthly child care allowance provided for by current legislation.
— The association consists of more than 420 thousand taxpayers of professional income tax, — she noted. — There are many working parents among them.
The conclusion of the State Duma Committee on Family Protection, Fatherhood, Motherhood and Childhood on the bill also noted a number of important comments on the proposed two-month restriction.
Parliamentarians emphasize that strict censorship can infringe on the rights of citizens who are forced to interrupt their vacation and return to work ahead of schedule due to objective life circumstances. Such reasons included a sharp decline in family income, unforeseen expenses for the needs of the child, or the loss of earnings by the second parent.
"At the same time, early retirement does not in itself indicate a lack of actual child care," the document says. — The parent can continue to take care of the child in their free time, including when arranging mutual care for the child by family members."
The deputies pointed out that the proposed version of the norm carries increased financial risks for the most vulnerable categories — the poor, large families, as well as those who find themselves in a difficult life situation. Therefore, it was proposed to finalize it: to clearly indicate in which cases parents will be able to go to work early and keep the allowance in order to avoid discrepancies and unjustified refusal of payments.
Why do we need restrictions?
In the explanatory notes to the draft laws, the need for changes is explained by the fight against abuse. The amendment should reduce the number of cases when vacations are issued for the sake of higher benefits, noted Anastasia Gorelkina, an economist and member of the Board of Directors of KAO Azot. Now it can be issued by a relative who has a higher salary.
"After a few days, the person returns to work, but another family member remains with the child," she noted. — A two-month period will complicate such registration, and you can check the length of the vacation using personnel documents. But the same condition applies to a mother who really cares for a child and after a month is forced to take a part-time job to cover the family's expenses. She will lose her allowance, although she will continue to spend a significant part of the day with her child.
The SR believes that such a requirement will not solve the problem. An unscrupulous benefit recipient will be able to spend two months on vacation, then return to work and continue receiving payments.
"At the same time, a conscientious parent who needs to return to work earlier due to insufficient family income will lose the payment in the same way," they said.
The same opinion is shared by the head of the Self-employment portal.online", expert of the coordination center under the Government of Russia Arseniy Belenky.
— The two-month rule does not eliminate those who abuse, — said the expert. — A person who has taken a vacation for the sake of payment will simply sit out these two months and continue to receive benefits. But a mom who needs to go to work earlier because the family doesn't have enough money will lose it.
In addition, it is not clear from the explanatory note how common such schemes are. It turns out that due to individual cases of abuse, the new restrictions may affect all parents, although it is not even known how common such situations are.
Risks of amendments
Parents should not be forced to choose between earnings and benefits when family expenses are particularly high, Marina Koyushkova emphasized.
"If the new rule comes into force, a parent who is forced to return to work before the child turns two months old will lose his payment before the child reaches the age of one and a half years," she explained. — At the same time, the additional income from self-employment will not cover the increased expenses of the family.
According to Arseny Belenky, for many parents, self—employment is a way to stay in the profession.
— You can take a couple of orders a week, keep customers and skills, but at the same time stay with the child, — he emphasized. — Going to work early does not mean that the parent cares less about the baby. The current rules apply only from 2024. Changing them now means undermining people's trust in government support. It is necessary to deal with abuse, but precisely, and not to take away the allowance from everyone who returned to work early.
The SRF proposes to maintain the current procedure, which allows parents to combine work with child care benefits without the requirement to stay on vacation for a minimum period. They were supported by the New Labor trade union.
— Two months without earnings is a serious test for a family where only one person works, for single parents, for those who pay the mortgage, — Alyona Lovochkina pointed out. — This is especially true for people with unstable incomes — the self-employed, freelancers, and platform workers. For them, dropping out of work for two months often means losing customers and orders that cannot be returned later.
At the same time, according to her, there are other risks. The norm makes it less profitable for mothers to go to work early, which the government has encouraged in recent years. The new rules may encourage some parents to take informal part-time jobs in the first months in order not to lose either income or benefits.
Experts stressed that it is necessary to combat abuse in a targeted manner. It is better to fix that the benefit is received by the one who actually takes care of the child: if the mother is on parental leave, but without payments, the benefit should be assigned to her, and not to a relative with a high salary. The right of parents to combine child care with work — for hire, with another employer, or as self—employed - must be preserved, they stressed.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»