- Статьи
- Economy
- They'll find justice: The Ministry of Construction supports strengthening control over the voting of homeowners
They'll find justice: The Ministry of Construction supports strengthening control over the voting of homeowners
The Ministry of Construction supported the initiative of State Duma deputies to tighten the fight against forgery of the results of general meetings of homeowners. At the same time, the agency proposed to finalize the draft law, in particular, to retain the requirement to indicate the location of the meeting if it is not held in electronic form. As the authors told Izvestia, the document will be submitted to the State Duma in a week, and the ministry's amendments will be taken into account in preparation for the second reading. What the bill will change and whether it will help to combat the falsification of decisions of general meetings of owners is in the Izvestia article.
Why do they want to tighten control over residents' meetings?
Russia is preparing to tighten control over the holding of meetings of homeowners in apartment buildings — the Ministry of Construction conceptually supported the need for regulation, follows from the agency's response to the relevant deputy bill, which was reviewed by Izvestia.
The bill, as Izvestia wrote, was prepared by Svetlana Razvorotneva, deputy chairman of the State Duma Committee on Construction and Housing and Communal Services, this summer in order to combat mass falsification of minutes of meetings of homeowners. To do this, it was proposed to abandon the in-person, absentee and in-person-absentee voting formats if there are more than 30 apartments in the house. At the same time, it was assumed that citizens would use two options for expressing their will — using GIS housing and communal services with the identification of each owner's decision through Gosuslugi or through an information system created by regional authorities.
The document also establishes a clear voting algorithm. The initiator sends a notification about it, after which the system generates a newsletter in the prescribed form with a unique number. In addition, it is proposed to abandon the transfer of the original protocols to management companies, HOAs and housing and communal services and their subsequent storage in the State Housing Inspectorate (GJI). According to the authors, the documents will be sent there in electronic form, which will make it possible to abandon paper storage in local governments. It was during the transfer through intermediaries, as noted in the initiative, that falsification of protocols often occurred.
"The Ministry of Construction conceptually supports the need to improve these institutions of housing legislation," the ministry's response says.
At the same time, the agency suggests taking into account a number of comments and finalizing the initiative. In particular, instead of self-posting an ad, it is proposed to automatically generate a message about voting in the information system. According to the Ministry of Construction, this will reduce the risk of counterfeiting. At the same time, the ministry considers it necessary to keep the ads in publicly accessible places — on information stands in all entrances or on the territory of the house.
In addition, the Ministry of Construction proposes to retain the requirement to indicate the place of voting in case it takes place without using an information system.
— The in-person and absentee voting form has been retained for houses with fewer than 30 apartments. They can vote however they like. Other comments that can be called technical are not critical either. Therefore, we will take them into account when considering the bill in the second reading, and I think it will be submitted to the State Duma in a week," Svetlana Razvorotneva told Izvestia.
Izvestia sent a request to the Ministry of Construction with a request to comment on the conceptual support for the initiative and the agency's proposals for its refinement.
Pros and cons of stricter controls
As Izvestia wrote, cases of falsification of minutes of general meetings of homeowners occur throughout Russia, and their consequences affect ordinary citizens.
Thus, the editorial office had at its disposal documents about a controversial change of management organization in one of the Moscow apartment buildings on Trade Union Street. Since 1976, it has been managed by the Galaktika Housing and Construction Cooperative. According to the residents, in 2025, a certain group of owners initiated a general meeting of residents, which considered the issue of transferring control of the house to GBU Zhilishchnik Akademicheskiy district. The minutes of the meeting were sent to the Moscow Housing Inspectorate, while, according to residents, not all owners signed the document. Despite this, the agency approved it, after which Zhilishchnik was officially appointed the managing organization.
However, according to residents, the new management organization has not actually started servicing the house. According to them, all work on the maintenance and repair of the house is still carried out by Galaktika's forces and at the expense of Galaktika, however, residents receive receipts for services from two organizations - Zhilishchnik and HBC Galaktika.
An ambiguous situation has developed in the Zaozerye microdistrict in Perm. As its residents told Izvestia, the owners of four apartment buildings decided to change the management company of the management company "MKD Asset" to the management company "Prestigious House", but when submitting documents to the IGZHN, it turned out that they had been beaten. The management company "MKD Asset" has already submitted a protocol to the IGJN, where, according to the residents, she allegedly signed for all the owners of the MKD (living and dead). The owners wrote statements about the falsification of ballots, but IGJN ignored them all. As a result, the apartment owners of all the houses submitted a collective statement to the prosecutor's office about the forgery of the Criminal Code "MKD Asset" of the minutes of the general meeting of the owners of the premises in the MKD.
Earlier, a case of possible forgery of signatures of residents of one of the capital's high-rise buildings also received a large-scale response, REN TV reported. Its residents allegedly agreed to the construction of an extension to the house, which now threatens the entire building. It turned out that more than 70 signatures were fake. Residents are trying to find out through the court who forged their signatures, and to achieve the demolition of the illegal building while the house is still standing.
Vera Moskvina, executive Director of the Moscow City Housing and Communal Services Control Association, told Izvestia that she would support the deputies' initiative.
— Of course, it is necessary to increase the transparency of residents' voting. It's good if everything is recorded in digital format, because according to current legislation, it is very difficult to legitimately hold a general meeting of homeowners," she believes.
In her opinion, it is necessary to generally work on improving housing legislation so that participants in housing and communal relations are not in constant confrontation.
However, there was no support for the initiative from the management companies. Tatiana Gotsulenko, director of the Association of Management and Maintenance Organizations in the Housing Sector, told Izvestia that the norms proposed by the deputies did not deserve support. According to her, it is incorrect to say that most of the minutes of residents' meetings are forged, although it is difficult to deny such cases. According to her, in Russia "owners are very inert, and according to the Housing Code, a number of procedures require a decision by the owners' meeting." Therefore, in order to carry out any housework, it is necessary to adopt the minutes of the general meeting's decision. In addition, the representative of the Criminal Code noted that sometimes organizations are forced to make some fictitious contributions of votes, since there is no other way to make decisions on important communal problems of the residents themselves.
Konstantin Krokhin, a member of the Housing and Communal Services Committee of the Chamber of Commerce and Industry, also believes that the problem lies not only in the lack of control, but also in the unwillingness of residents themselves to actively participate in such votes. In addition, the legislation assumes that in order to challenge the voting results, it is necessary to find 21% of active residents who will oppose, which is often impossible due to the inactivity of citizens, and fraudsters take advantage of this.
Pavel Shapkin, Chairman of the National Consumer Rights Protection Union, on the contrary, believes that the bill should be adopted as soon as possible. According to him, the population has almost no confidence in the results of voting at such meetings. According to him, it is high time to restore order and make the housing and communal services system transparent, so that people can be sure that it is their decision that has been made, and not the decision of an interested management company, including raising tariffs and the cost of services.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»