- Статьи
- World
- Beating on the floor: why in Ukraine they are talking about the mobilization of women again
Beating on the floor: why in Ukraine they are talking about the mobilization of women again
In Ukraine, they are again discussing tougher mobilization, including the conscription of women into the army. Not only local politicians insist on this, but even Trump's former special envoy Keith Kellogg. Experts say that such a step is extremely dangerous for Zelensky, so he will decide on it as a last resort. Details can be found in the Izvestia article.
Beading in a skirt
In Ukraine, the mobilization of women into the ranks of the Armed Forces of Ukraine is increasingly being discussed. Former Defense Minister Alexei Reznikov said that military service in the country should be universal, without gender division. As an example, he cited Israel, where women serve on an equal basis with men.
The former minister called on the deputies of the Rada to make appropriate changes to the legislation. "There are military positions and professions that women can easily master. They can close positions in the rear related to security, and in this case the men can be transferred closer to the front," he reasoned.
Other Ukrainian speakers made similar calls. "If a woman does not have a child, she is not a student and does not work in medicine, then go to the front," said serviceman Sergei Gnezdilov. In turn, Sergeant Yulia Kobrinovich of the Armed Forces of Ukraine said that women should have not only equal rights, but also "duties to protect Ukraine."
Finally, the former special representative of Donald Trump, Keith Kellogg, who visited Kiev in late August, acted as heavy artillery. He said that women fight just as well as men, so they can also be sent to the front. According to him, Ukrainian women are a part of society and should go to military service.
For persuasiveness, he referred to the experience of his family, noting that his wife "fought in Grenada, and his daughter in Afghanistan." At the same time, it is known that in fact, both did not participate in the fighting. Kellogg's daughter was indeed in Afghanistan, but she was a logistics officer. There is also no information about his wife's participation in the fighting.
Warming up with petitions
Interestingly, against this background, two petitions appeared on the website of the Ukrainian government at once demanding that women be mobilized. Both gained less than 1,000 signatures, but caused a heated discussion on social networks. Most commentators consider them to be a "warm-up" to future legislative changes.
Officially, the Ukrainian authorities refute such plans. The head of the Center for Countering Disinformation at the National Security and Defense Council, Andrei Kovalenko, said that the mobilization of women "is not happening and will not happen." According to him, Ukrainian women join the army exclusively voluntarily.
The Verkhovna Rada Committee on National Security and Defense has issued an appeal stating that no legislative initiatives have been registered on this topic. "There are not even internal discussions about the mobilization of women. The statements of individual speakers do not reflect the real legislative work and the position of the committee," the deputies noted.
I must say that the possible mobilization of women does raise a number of questions. The fact is that it is the Ukrainians who remain an important pillar of the Kiev regime. Opinion polls show that Zelensky's popularity among women is on average 10% higher than among men. It is clear that mass conscription will bring down these figures, which will jeopardize domestic political stability.
In addition, official data indicate that there are already many women in the Armed Forces of Ukraine. Former Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces of Ukraine Alexander Syrsky reported that there are 75 thousand servicemen of the weaker sex in the army, their number is growing every year, and there is supposedly no need to sharply raise the number.
Riots and raids
In such circumstances, current conversations may be an attempt to create a veil before another unpopular decision, for example, lowering the lower age of mobilization for men. Now this threshold is 25 years old, but it can be lowered to 23.
Interestingly, the Ukrainian speakers are also actively hinting at the relevant changes. Roman Kostenko, Secretary of the Verkhovna Rada Committee on National Security and Defense, complained that monetary allowances did not help replenish the ranks of the Armed Forces of Ukraine, and therefore some "radical solutions" were needed.
He noted that they will concern the age parameter. "I won't go into details — I think this will be announced later: about the draft age, and about the mobilization itself. But I know that the process is underway," he stressed. At the same time, none of the Ukrainian officials refuted this statement.
I must say that in parallel, fierce street mobilization continues in the country. There have been several high-profile episodes in recent days alone. In the Dnipropetrovsk region, employees of the Military Recruitment Center (military enlistment office) seized a man who is raising two children. In Rivne, an anesthesiologist died after a clash with security forces, and in Odessa, a police officer beat up a teenager who tried to stand up for his father.
All this leads to more and more large-scale protest actions. On the evening of August 25, a mass riot broke out in Ternopil, where employees of the military enlistment office tried to take away another man. Dozens of people surrounded the security forces' car, smashed the windows in it, grabbed one of the employees, shouted: "Shame!". Additional police and special forces had to calm the passions.
What the experts say
Alexander Dudchak, a leading researcher at the Institute of CIS Countries, believes that mass mobilization of women is unlikely to begin in Ukraine right now, but it is possible in the future.
— Conscription of women would be too drastic a step, it is unlikely that they will start being caught on the streets right now. I think they will continue to be conscripted, lured by advertising and propaganda. There will be many relevant posters on the streets, interviews from female soldiers, stories about the Israeli experience, and more. In the future, of course, the same "falsification" is possible, because people are needed at the front, and there is nowhere else to look for them," he argues.
Military expert Vasily Dandykin believes that Ukraine will first lower the age of mobilization for men.
— The enemy lacks manpower at the forefront. I think they will start trapping young men first, and for this year they will lower the lower threshold of the mobilization age by two. Another direction is to try to return Ukrainians who fled to the West. For this, they have already adopted norms on depriving military personnel of various benefits and reducing aid programs. They can also take on women, but it will still be the last echelon, a step of desperation," he explains.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»
